Skip to main content
Back to Bills
OntarioDid Not Pass43rd Parliament, 1st Session

Bill 184 explained in plain English

Supporting Mobility, Affordability and Reliable Transportation in Ontario Act, 2024

Ontario legislature bill summary, status, timeline, sponsor, votes, and official sources.

At a glance

Jurisdiction
Ontario Legislature
Legislature / Parliament
Legislative Assembly of Ontario
Session
43rd Parliament, 1st Session
Bill number
Bill 184
Full title
Supporting Mobility, Affordability and Reliable Transportation in Ontario Act, 2024
Current status
Did Not Pass
Latest event
Lost on division
Last updated
Apr 25, 2024

Official Legislative Assembly of Ontario snapshot for 43rd Parliament, 1st Session. Representative vote breakdowns appear when the Assembly publishes an Ayes and Nays page for the bill.

Chamber
Legislative Assembly of Ontario
Current Stage
Lost on division
Latest Activity
Apr 25, 2024
Plain-language explanation
In plain English (our explanation)

Our plain-language take, written for civic education.

Source: By PoliticalData.ca

AI-assisted, reviewed before publishing
Short Version

Bill 184 amends Ontario transportation laws to expand Metrolinx's role in bike share systems, require affordable housing when Metrolinx sells land for residential development, set highway maintenance standards for three major highways, and establish a process for shortline railway companies to discontinue service.

What It Means

Bill 184 amends three Ontario transportation laws. It updates the Metrolinx Act, 2006 to give Metrolinx a new responsibility to promote and coordinate municipal bike share systems (integrating their routes, fares, and schedules). It also requires that when Metrolinx sells or disposes of assets for building residential units, at least 20 per cent of those units must be affordable housing as defined in the Development Charges Act, 1997. The bill amends the Public Transportation and Highway Improvement Act to set mandatory maintenance standards for Highways 11, 17, and 69 (including two-lane sections). The standards require: snow removal within four hours after snowfall ends, ice clearance within three hours of discovery, and pothole repairs within four days for potholes larger than 600 square centimetres and deeper than eight centimetres. The bill also amends the Shortline Railways Act, 1995 to restore and set out requirements for shortline railway companies that want to stop operating a railway line. Companies must advertise their intention in local newspapers, give at least 30 days for interested parties to express interest, negotiate in good faith, and offer the line to the Ontario government or affected municipalities at net salvage value if no private agreement is reached. If parties disagree on the value, an independent appraiser or arbitrator determines it.

What This Bill Does
  • Adds to Metrolinx Act, 2006 a requirement that Metrolinx promote and facilitate integration of routes, fares, and schedules of municipal bike share systems
  • Requires Metrolinx or subsidiary corporations to ensure at least 20 per cent of residential units are affordable (as defined in the Development Charges Act, 1997) when selling or disposing of assets for residential building purposes
  • Adds mandatory maintenance standards to the Public Transportation and Highway Improvement Act for Highways 11, 17, and 69: snow removal within four hours after snowfall ends, ice clearance within three hours of discovery, and pothole repair within four days for potholes exceeding 600 square centimetres in surface area and eight centimetres in depth
  • Restores and establishes requirements in the Shortline Railways Act, 1995 for shortline railway companies discontinuing operations: they must advertise in local newspapers, allow at least 30 days for interested parties to respond, negotiate in good faith, and offer the railway line to the Ontario government and affected municipalities at net salvage value if no private agreement is reached
  • Provides a dispute resolution process (independent appraiser or arbitrator) to determine net salvage value if parties cannot agree
Who Is Affected
  • Metrolinx and any subsidiary corporations that sell or dispose of assets for residential development
  • Ontario municipalities with municipal bike share systems
  • The Ontario government and municipalities affected by shortline railway discontinuances
  • Shortline railway companies operating in Ontario
  • Drivers and users of Highways 11, 17, and 69
  • Interested parties (individuals or organizations) who wish to acquire, lease, or operate a shortline railway line slated for discontinuance
Rights, Duties, Or Obligations
  • Metrolinx must promote and facilitate integration of municipal bike share system routes, fares, and schedules
  • When Metrolinx sells or disposes of assets for residential building, it must ensure at least 20 per cent of units are affordable residential units
  • The Ontario Minister responsible for highways must ensure Highways 11, 17, and 69 are maintained to the specified standards: snow removal within four hours, ice clearance within three hours, and pothole repair within four days for qualifying potholes
  • Shortline railway companies must advertise discontinuance intentions in local newspapers and notify the registrar
  • Shortline railway companies must allow at least 30 days for interested parties to express interest and must negotiate in good faith
  • If no private agreement is reached within 90 days, shortline railway companies must offer the line to the Ontario government and municipalities at net salvage value
  • The Ontario government and municipalities have 30 days to accept an offer to purchase/lease a railway line at net salvage value
  • Interested parties have a right to be informed of the process for evaluating offers to acquire a shortline railway line
Important Dates
  • Most of the Act comes into force on the day it receives Royal Assent
  • Section 2 (affordable housing requirement for Metrolinx asset sales) comes into force on the later of: (a) the day Section 3 of Schedule 3 to the More Homes Built Faster Act, 2022 comes into force, or (b) the day this Act receives Royal Assent
  • Shortline railway companies must allow at least 30 days from first publication of advertisement for interested parties to express interest
  • Shortline railway companies must negotiate for 90 days after the final interest date or offer the line to government and municipalities
  • Government and municipalities have 30 days to accept an offer to purchase/lease a railway line
Financial Or Tax Impacts
  • Metrolinx must ensure at least 20 per cent of residential units are affordable when selling/disposing of assets, which may reduce revenue or require financial adjustments
  • Highway maintenance obligations (snow removal, ice clearance, pothole repair) will create ongoing costs for the Ontario government
  • Costs of independent appraisers for shortline railway valuation disputes are shared equally between parties
Enforcement Or Penalties
  • The bill text does not specify explicit penalties or enforcement mechanisms for violations of the highway maintenance standards or the affordable housing requirement
  • The bill text does not specify explicit penalties for shortline railway companies that fail to comply with discontinuance procedures, though the process includes dispute resolution through independent appraisers and arbitrators
Uncertainties Or Limits
  • The bill does not define what constitutes 'integration' of bike share routes, fares, and schedules or provide specific mechanisms for Metrolinx to achieve this
  • The bill does not specify what happens if Metrolinx cannot find a way to meet the 20 per cent affordable housing requirement when selling land
  • The bill does not state consequences if the highway maintenance standards are not met
  • The definition of 'affordable residential units' is incorporated by reference from the Development Charges Act, 1997, which is not included in this bill text
  • The bill does not clarify how 'net salvage value' is to be determined initially or provide detailed guidance on the appraisal or arbitration process
  • The bill text does not indicate whether Section 2 (affordable housing) has been proclaimed in force, since its commencement depends on a section of the More Homes Built Faster Act, 2022
Laws Or Regulations Affected
Metrolinx Act, 2006
amends

Adds a new responsibility for Metrolinx to promote and facilitate integration of municipal bike share systems' routes, fares, and schedules; requires Metrolinx to ensure at least 20 per cent of residential units are affordable when selling or disposing of assets for residential development

Source: Sections 1 and 2

Public Transportation and Highway Improvement Act
amends

Adds new Section 100 establishing mandatory maintenance standards for Highways 11, 17, and 69, requiring snow removal within four hours, ice clearance within three hours, and pothole repair within four days for larger potholes

Source: Section 3

Shortline Railways Act, 1995
amends

Re-enacts Section 10 (previously repealed) establishing a process for shortline railway companies to discontinue operations, including advertising requirements, a 30-day notice period, good faith negotiation requirements, and a mandatory offer to sell/lease/transfer to the Ontario government and municipalities at net salvage value if private agreements fail

Source: Section 4

Development Charges Act, 1997
referenced

Bill references the definition of 'affordable residential units' from this Act when establishing Metrolinx's obligation regarding affordable housing

Source: Section 2

Generated using AI from official bill text. Not legal advice. It is written by PoliticalData.ca for civic education, automatically checked and spot-reviewed before publishing.

Official text

Process Snapshot

Step 1
First reading
Apr 9, 2024
Step 2
Second reading
Apr 25, 2024
Step 3
Committee review
Not reached yet
Step 4
Third reading
Not reached yet
Step 5
Royal assent
Not reached yet

Vote Summary

Yes
27
No
61
Abstain
0
Absent / Other
0
Final recorded vote
Apr 25, 2024
88 representative positions are recorded in this official snapshot for this vote.
Sponsor
Andrea Hazell
Ontario Liberal Party | Scarborough—Guildwood
Jurisdiction
Ontario Legislature

Representative Voting Breakdown

Vote badges include text labels so the table stays readable for everyone, even without color cues alone.

RepresentativeRoleRidingPartyVoteNotes
MPP
MPPScarborough—GuildwoodOntario Liberal PartyYesRecorded without an additional note.
MPPDon Valley EastOntario Liberal PartyYesRecorded without an additional note.
MPPKitchener CentreGreen Party of OntarioYesRecorded without an additional note.
MPPParkdale—High ParkNew Democratic Party of OntarioYesRecorded without an additional note.
MPPWaterlooNew Democratic Party of OntarioYesRecorded without an additional note.
MPPOttawa West—NepeanNew Democratic Party of OntarioYesRecorded without an additional note.
MPPSpadina—Fort YorkNew Democratic Party of OntarioYesRecorded without an additional note.
MPPMushkegowuk—James BayNew Democratic Party of OntarioYesRecorded without an additional note.
MPPSudburyNew Democratic Party of OntarioYesRecorded without an additional note.
MPPNiagara CentreNew Democratic Party of OntarioYesRecorded without an additional note.
MPPOshawaNew Democratic Party of OntarioYesRecorded without an additional note.
MPPUniversity—RosedaleNew Democratic Party of OntarioYesRecorded without an additional note.
MPPOttawa CentreNew Democratic Party of OntarioYesRecorded without an additional note.
MPPOttawa SouthOntario Liberal PartyYesRecorded without an additional note.
MPPTimiskaming—CochraneNew Democratic Party of OntarioYesRecorded without an additional note.
MPPToronto CentreNew Democratic Party of OntarioYesRecorded without an additional note.
MPPDavenportNew Democratic Party of OntarioYesRecorded without an additional note.
MPPBeaches—East YorkOntario Liberal PartyYesRecorded without an additional note.
MPPHamilton MountainNew Democratic Party of OntarioYesRecorded without an additional note.
MPPLondon WestNew Democratic Party of OntarioYesRecorded without an additional note.
MPPToronto—DanforthNew Democratic Party of OntarioYesRecorded without an additional note.
MPPKiiwetinoongNew Democratic Party of OntarioYesRecorded without an additional note.
MPPDon Valley WestOntario Liberal PartyYesRecorded without an additional note.
MPPOrléansOntario Liberal PartyYesRecorded without an additional note.
MPPLondon North CentreNew Democratic Party of OntarioYesRecorded without an additional note.
MPPLondon—FanshaweNew Democratic Party of OntarioYesRecorded without an additional note.
MPPNiagara FallsNew Democratic Party of OntarioYesRecorded without an additional note.
MPPBrampton WestProgressive Conservative Party of OntarioNoRecorded without an additional note.
MPPWindsor—TecumsehProgressive Conservative Party of OntarioNoRecorded without an additional note.
MPPEssexProgressive Conservative Party of OntarioNoRecorded without an additional note.
MPPScarborough—AgincourtProgressive Conservative Party of OntarioNoRecorded without an additional note.
MPPMarkham—UnionvilleProgressive Conservative Party of OntarioNoRecorded without an additional note.
MPPCambridgeProgressive Conservative Party of OntarioNoRecorded without an additional note.
MPPEtobicoke—LakeshoreProgressive Conservative Party of OntarioNoRecorded without an additional note.
MPPRichmond HillProgressive Conservative Party of OntarioNoRecorded without an additional note.
MPPPeterborough—KawarthaProgressive Conservative Party of OntarioNoRecorded without an additional note.
MPPScarborough CentreProgressive Conservative Party of OntarioNoRecorded without an additional note.
MPPNewmarket—AuroraProgressive Conservative Party of OntarioNoRecorded without an additional note.
MPPMississauga—MaltonProgressive Conservative Party of OntarioNoRecorded without an additional note.
MPPOakville North—BurlingtonProgressive Conservative Party of OntarioNoRecorded without an additional note.
MPPCarletonIndependentNoRecorded without an additional note.
MPPYork—SimcoeProgressive Conservative Party of OntarioNoRecorded without an additional note.
MPPBrampton CentreProgressive Conservative Party of OntarioNoRecorded without an additional note.
MPPNorthumberland—Peterborough SouthProgressive Conservative Party of OntarioNoRecorded without an additional note.
MPPFlamborough—GlanbrookProgressive Conservative Party of OntarioNoRecorded without an additional note.
MPPOxfordProgressive Conservative Party of OntarioNoRecorded without an additional note.
MPPTimminsProgressive Conservative Party of OntarioNoRecorded without an additional note.
MPPBrampton NorthProgressive Conservative Party of OntarioNoRecorded without an additional note.
MPPEtobicoke CentreProgressive Conservative Party of OntarioNoRecorded without an additional note.
MPPHaliburton—Kawartha Lakes—BrockProgressive Conservative Party of OntarioNoRecorded without an additional note.
MPPHuron—BruceProgressive Conservative Party of OntarioNoRecorded without an additional note.
MPPAurora—Oak Ridges—Richmond HillProgressive Conservative Party of OntarioNoRecorded without an additional note.
MPPYork CentreProgressive Conservative Party of OntarioNoRecorded without an additional note.
MPPKitchener—ConestogaProgressive Conservative Party of OntarioNoRecorded without an additional note.
MPPHamilton East—Stoney CreekProgressive Conservative Party of OntarioNoRecorded without an additional note.
MPPMississauga—StreetsvilleProgressive Conservative Party of OntarioNoRecorded without an additional note.
MPPStormont—Dundas—South GlengarryProgressive Conservative Party of OntarioNoRecorded without an additional note.
MPPMarkham—StouffvilleProgressive Conservative Party of OntarioNoRecorded without an additional note.
MPPBrampton SouthProgressive Conservative Party of OntarioNoRecorded without an additional note.
MPPScarborough NorthProgressive Conservative Party of OntarioNoRecorded without an additional note.
MPPElgin—Middlesex—LondonProgressive Conservative Party of OntarioNoRecorded without an additional note.
MPPNiagara WestProgressive Conservative Party of OntarioNoRecorded without an additional note.
MPPWillowdaleProgressive Conservative Party of OntarioNoRecorded without an additional note.
MPPOakvilleProgressive Conservative Party of OntarioNoRecorded without an additional note.
MPPLeeds—Grenville—Thousand Islands and Rideau LakesProgressive Conservative Party of OntarioNoRecorded without an additional note.
MPPDurhamProgressive Conservative Party of OntarioNoRecorded without an additional note.
MPPChatham-Kent—LeamingtonProgressive Conservative Party of OntarioNoRecorded without an additional note.
MPPKitchener South—HespelerProgressive Conservative Party of OntarioNoRecorded without an additional note.
MPPLanark—Frontenac—KingstonProgressive Conservative Party of OntarioNoRecorded without an additional note.
MPPRenfrew—Nipissing—PembrokeProgressive Conservative Party of OntarioNoRecorded without an additional note.
MPPMississauga East—CooksvilleIndependentNoRecorded without an additional note.
MPPThornhillProgressive Conservative Party of OntarioNoRecorded without an additional note.
MPPNepeanProgressive Conservative Party of OntarioNoRecorded without an additional note.
MPPMarkham—ThornhillProgressive Conservative Party of OntarioNoRecorded without an additional note.
MPPWhitbyProgressive Conservative Party of OntarioNoRecorded without an additional note.
MPPPerth—WellingtonProgressive Conservative Party of OntarioNoRecorded without an additional note.
MPPYork South—WestonProgressive Conservative Party of OntarioNoRecorded without an additional note.
MPPBurlingtonProgressive Conservative Party of OntarioNoRecorded without an additional note.
MPPAjaxProgressive Conservative Party of OntarioNoRecorded without an additional note.
MPPHastings—Lennox and AddingtonProgressive Conservative Party of OntarioNoRecorded without an additional note.
MPPBruce—Grey—Owen SoundProgressive Conservative Party of OntarioNoRecorded without an additional note.
MPPEglinton—LawrenceProgressive Conservative Party of OntarioNoRecorded without an additional note.
MPPMississauga—LakeshoreProgressive Conservative Party of OntarioNoRecorded without an additional note.
MPPMississauga—Erin MillsProgressive Conservative Party of OntarioNoRecorded without an additional note.
MPPGlengarry—Prescott—RussellProgressive Conservative Party of OntarioNoRecorded without an additional note.
MPPBay of QuinteProgressive Conservative Party of OntarioNoRecorded without an additional note.
MPPDon Valley NorthIndependentNoRecorded without an additional note.
MPPBrantford—BrantProgressive Conservative Party of OntarioNoRecorded without an additional note.

Official sources

Status, sponsor, votes, and timeline on this page are drawn from these official legislative sources and public records. Each summary above is attributed to its own source.

How this data is sourced